Fragments on Hegel’s Phenomenology of Spirit

Below are a few reflections after teaching a module on Hegel's Phenomenology of Spirit this past week. My natural inclinations draw me to Schelling's Naturphilosophie, but every time I return to Hegel's writing after some time apart I start to worry I've allowed myself to fall into a caricatured understanding of his trickster-like dialectical method. I'm reminded of …

Diagramming German Idealism

I'm teaching an online graduate course called Mind and Nature in German Idealism this semester. Below I am sharing several diagrams that I've developed to depict Kant's transcendental method as it evolves through the first three critiques, as well as Fichte's radicalization of the Kantian project. I hope to continue developing this diagram to elucidate Schelling, Goethe, …

response to R. Scott Bakker on transcendental phenomenology and BBT

Anyone who posits some form of efficacy or constraint outside the natural order on the basis of some kind of interpretation of ‘experience’ has the same argumentative burden to discharge: How do you know? What justifies such an extraordinary (supernatural) posit?...What makes the question so pressing now is that their instrument, reflection, has finally found …

Phenomenology and Process Ontology: Evan Thompson, Merleau-Ponty, Whitehead, and the Growing Together of the Flesh of the World

I had a friendly exchange yesterday with the cognitive scientist and philosopher Evan Thompson about his debate earlier this year with another cognitive scientist Owen Flanagan. The two distinguished thinkers disagreed about whether physicalism as currently understood can provide an adequate account of consciousness. I wanted to revisit several of the themes Evan and I …

Is Physicalism Enough? Can Consciousness be Naturalized? – Owen Flanagan in dialogue with Evan Thompson

Check out the video from their exchange at Northwestern earlier this year. Below are some of my notes and reflections after watching... Owen Flanagan argues that physicalism is the only feasible view. Naturalism is the inference to the best explanation. Conscious states are brain states. At some point in evolutionary history, somehow dead matter came to …