“Philosophy begins in wonder. And, at the end, when philosophic thought has done its best, the wonder remains.”
—Alfred North Whitehead
Recent Posts
- Stream on Capitol Insurrection January 10, 2021
- “How does matter give rise to consciousness?” (response to Sam Harris) January 3, 2021
- A review of Michael Hogue’s “American Immanence: Democracy for an Uncertain World” (2018) December 18, 2020
- Voices of VR podcast: A Primer on Whitehead’s Process Philosophy December 10, 2020
- Who are we? (thinking w/ Berry and Swimme) December 9, 2020
- Thinking with Carlo Rovelli: The Physics of Consciousness December 3, 2020
- Science and the Soul of the World: Participatory Knowing in Goethe and Whitehead November 25, 2020
- Dialoguing with Philip Goff about Consciousness, Panpsychism, and Process Philosophy November 18, 2020
- Concrescence and the Implicate Order: Whitehead and Bohm in Dialogue November 8, 2020
- Election Coverage: Live-streaming on Growing Down November 3, 2020
- Consciousness between Science and Philosophy (response to Philip Goff on panpsychism) October 30, 2020
- Apology for a Democratic Ontology (response to Keith Woods) October 29, 2020
- Rune Soup Podcast with Gordon White: Talking Whitehead, Plato, & Panpsychism October 24, 2020
- Thinking Cosmologically with Whitehead October 21, 2020
- Towards a Marian Consciousness (Ep. 1 of the Great American Road Trip Diaries) October 21, 2020
- Alchemical Consciousness After Descartes: Whitehead’s Philosophy of Organism as Psychedelic Realism October 15, 2020
- American Immanental Philosophies and the Future of Theopolitics: Dialoging with Michael Hogue October 15, 2020
- The brain is not a computer, and thinking is not information-processing. October 14, 2020
- “The Great American Trip,” dialogue on “Growing Down” October 10, 2020
- Rupert Sheldrake on Whitehead September 26, 2020
- Reason, Reality, & Religion in the Making (dialoguing with John Vervaeke) September 13, 2020
- Naturphilosophie as Process Philosophy in Schelling and Whitehead August 30, 2020
- Meta-Linguistics (dialoguing with Layman Pascal) August 29, 2020
- Metamodernism, the Integral Left, and Postmodern Traditionalism (dialoguing with Brent Cooper) August 27, 2020
- Parsimonious Panpsychism? (response to Julian Walker) August 25, 2020
- Emergent Evolution in a Panpsychist Cosmos (dialoging with Corey Anton) August 22, 2020
- Setting the Akashic Record Straight (final response to David Long about emergence and panpsychism) August 21, 2020
- What is at stake in cosmological inquiry? August 20, 2020
- Cosmologies in Question: A Debate with David Long August 19, 2020
- Consciousness in the Wild August 17, 2020
- Toward an Integral “God” – a dialogue with Layman Pascal August 14, 2020
- Death Denial in a Panpsychist Cosmos: A Dialogue with Corey Anton August 11, 2020
- Meta-Politics – a discussion with Layman Pascal on “The Integral Stage” August 8, 2020
- Remembering and Carrying Forward Michael Brooks on “Growing Down” July 25, 2020
- Dialogue with a Whiteheadian Thelemite Vajrayanist Wiccan, Sam Webster July 22, 2020
- The Rheomode Series, a YouTube playlist July 16, 2020
- Integral Entheogens (Ep. 5) – Molecular Alchemy and the Evolution of Spirit July 16, 2020
- Growing Down Podcast on “the Integral Left” July 4, 2020
- Dialoguing with Brent Cooper about ecosocialist politics and integral spirituality June 9, 2020
- “He maketh his sun to rise,” featuring Donald Trump, Cornel West, and Ram Dass June 4, 2020
- The Place of Psychedelic Chemistry/Alchemical Consciousness in Philosophy May 8, 2020
- Imagination as the Topographical Inversion of Reality: Musings with Becca Tarnas May 7, 2020
- Episode 6 of The Future Faces of Spirit April 25, 2020
- Reading and Riffing on Murray Bookchin’s “The Ecology of Freedom” April 15, 2020
- Prayers to a Process-Relational God April 12, 2020
- Ecological Civilization, or Anarcho-Primitivism? March 30, 2020
- Imagining a Gaian Reality After the Virus March 23, 2020
- Thoughts on William James, Pure Experience, and Materialism February 2, 2020
- Musing on “Consciousness” with William James & Alfred North Whitehead January 31, 2020
- What is life? interview with Tim Freke January 17, 2020
#occupy
aesthetics
alchemy
Anima mundi
Anthropos
archetypal cosmology
atheism
biology
Buddhism
burning man
capitalism
causality
Chaos
Christ
christianity
cognitive science
Consciousness
Cosmogenesis
cosmology
cosmopolitics
cosmotheandric
creativity
death
earth
ecological crisis
ecology
economics
emergence
eternal object
etheric imagination
evolution
Evolution of consciousness
freedom
Gaia
German Idealism
god
imagination
integral
language
life
logos
love
materialism
media ecology
metaphysics
mind
myth
nature
Naturphilosophie
neuroscience
Object-oriented ontology
Ontology
organism
Panpsychism
phenomenology
philosophy
physics
play
pluralism
politics
Process
Process philosophy
Psychedelics
Religion
science
soul
soul-making
space-time
Spirit
spirituality
technology
teleology
theology
time
world-soul
Alan Watts Albert Einstein Alfred North Whitehead Ancient Philosophy Aristotle autopoiesis Brian Swimme Bruno Latour Carl Jung Catherine Keller Coleridge Copernican Revolution Daniel Dennett Darwin David Chalmers Descartes Donna Haraway Edmund Husserl Evan Thompson Extended Mind Fichte Francisco Varela galileo Gilles Deleuze Goethe Graham Harman Hegel Heidegger henri bergson Hume Iain Hamilton Grant imagination Isabelle Stengers Jakob Böhme James Hillman Jean Gebser john Keats Kant kepler Levi Bryant Modern Philosophy Owen Barfield Pierre Teilhard de Chardin Plato poetry politics PZ Myers quentin meillassoux race Raimon Panikkar Ralph Waldo Emerson Ray Brassier reason Religion Richard Dawkins Richard Tarnas Robert N. Bellah Romantic Philosophy rudolf steiner Schelling Sean Kelly Socrates speculative realism Spinoza Steven Shaviro Thomas Berry Timothy Morton Travel William James Wittgenstein
Posts I Like
Archives
Top Clicks
- academia.edu/27796967/2016_Shook_Pa…
- schumachercollege.org.uk/courses/sh…
- stephenerobbins.com/talks/Relativit…
- ciis.edu/faculty-and-staff-director…
- docs.google.com/document/d/1Gdm16zr…
- matthewsegall.files.wordpress.com/2…
- matthewsegall.files.wordpress.com/2…
- matthewsegall.files.wordpress.com/2…
- tomcarter12.wordpress.com
- garygoldbergmd.wordpress.com
Copyright

footnotes2plato.com by Matthew David Segall is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Blog Stats
- 641,908 hits
Albert Einstein Alfred North Whitehead Ancient Philosophy Aristotle autopoiesis Brian Swimme Bruno Latour Carl Jung Coleridge Copernican Revolution Daniel Dennett Darwin Descartes Edmund Husserl Evan Thompson Fichte Francisco Varela galileo Gilles Deleuze Goethe Graham Harman Hegel Heidegger henri bergson Hume Iain Hamilton Grant imagination Isabelle Stengers Jakob Böhme Jean Gebser Kant kepler Levi Bryant Modern Philosophy Owen Barfield Pierre Teilhard de Chardin Plato poetry politics race reason Religion Richard Dawkins Richard Tarnas Romantic Philosophy rudolf steiner Schelling Sean Kelly speculative realism William James
Recent Posts
- Stream on Capitol Insurrection January 10, 2021
- “How does matter give rise to consciousness?” (response to Sam Harris) January 3, 2021
- A review of Michael Hogue’s “American Immanence: Democracy for an Uncertain World” (2018) December 18, 2020
- Voices of VR podcast: A Primer on Whitehead’s Process Philosophy December 10, 2020
- Who are we? (thinking w/ Berry and Swimme) December 9, 2020
- Thinking with Carlo Rovelli: The Physics of Consciousness December 3, 2020
- Science and the Soul of the World: Participatory Knowing in Goethe and Whitehead November 25, 2020
- Dialoguing with Philip Goff about Consciousness, Panpsychism, and Process Philosophy November 18, 2020
- Concrescence and the Implicate Order: Whitehead and Bohm in Dialogue November 8, 2020
- Election Coverage: Live-streaming on Growing Down November 3, 2020
- Consciousness between Science and Philosophy (response to Philip Goff on panpsychism) October 30, 2020
- Apology for a Democratic Ontology (response to Keith Woods) October 29, 2020
- Rune Soup Podcast with Gordon White: Talking Whitehead, Plato, & Panpsychism October 24, 2020
- Thinking Cosmologically with Whitehead October 21, 2020
- Towards a Marian Consciousness (Ep. 1 of the Great American Road Trip Diaries) October 21, 2020
- Alchemical Consciousness After Descartes: Whitehead’s Philosophy of Organism as Psychedelic Realism October 15, 2020
- American Immanental Philosophies and the Future of Theopolitics: Dialoging with Michael Hogue October 15, 2020
- The brain is not a computer, and thinking is not information-processing. October 14, 2020
- “The Great American Trip,” dialogue on “Growing Down” October 10, 2020
- Rupert Sheldrake on Whitehead September 26, 2020
- Reason, Reality, & Religion in the Making (dialoguing with John Vervaeke) September 13, 2020
- Naturphilosophie as Process Philosophy in Schelling and Whitehead August 30, 2020
- Meta-Linguistics (dialoguing with Layman Pascal) August 29, 2020
- Metamodernism, the Integral Left, and Postmodern Traditionalism (dialoguing with Brent Cooper) August 27, 2020
- Parsimonious Panpsychism? (response to Julian Walker) August 25, 2020
- Emergent Evolution in a Panpsychist Cosmos (dialoging with Corey Anton) August 22, 2020
- Setting the Akashic Record Straight (final response to David Long about emergence and panpsychism) August 21, 2020
- What is at stake in cosmological inquiry? August 20, 2020
- Cosmologies in Question: A Debate with David Long August 19, 2020
- Consciousness in the Wild August 17, 2020
- Toward an Integral “God” – a dialogue with Layman Pascal August 14, 2020
- Death Denial in a Panpsychist Cosmos: A Dialogue with Corey Anton August 11, 2020
- Meta-Politics – a discussion with Layman Pascal on “The Integral Stage” August 8, 2020
- Remembering and Carrying Forward Michael Brooks on “Growing Down” July 25, 2020
- Dialogue with a Whiteheadian Thelemite Vajrayanist Wiccan, Sam Webster July 22, 2020
- The Rheomode Series, a YouTube playlist July 16, 2020
- Integral Entheogens (Ep. 5) – Molecular Alchemy and the Evolution of Spirit July 16, 2020
- Growing Down Podcast on “the Integral Left” July 4, 2020
- Dialoguing with Brent Cooper about ecosocialist politics and integral spirituality June 9, 2020
- “He maketh his sun to rise,” featuring Donald Trump, Cornel West, and Ram Dass June 4, 2020
- The Place of Psychedelic Chemistry/Alchemical Consciousness in Philosophy May 8, 2020
- Imagination as the Topographical Inversion of Reality: Musings with Becca Tarnas May 7, 2020
- Episode 6 of The Future Faces of Spirit April 25, 2020
- Reading and Riffing on Murray Bookchin’s “The Ecology of Freedom” April 15, 2020
- Prayers to a Process-Relational God April 12, 2020
- Ecological Civilization, or Anarcho-Primitivism? March 30, 2020
- Imagining a Gaian Reality After the Virus March 23, 2020
- Thoughts on William James, Pure Experience, and Materialism February 2, 2020
- Musing on “Consciousness” with William James & Alfred North Whitehead January 31, 2020
- What is life? interview with Tim Freke January 17, 2020
#occupy
aesthetics
alchemy
Anima mundi
Anthropos
archetypal cosmology
atheism
biology
Buddhism
burning man
capitalism
causality
Chaos
Christ
christianity
cognitive science
Consciousness
Cosmogenesis
cosmology
cosmopolitics
cosmotheandric
creativity
death
earth
ecological crisis
ecology
economics
emergence
eternal object
etheric imagination
evolution
Evolution of consciousness
freedom
Gaia
German Idealism
god
imagination
integral
language
life
logos
love
materialism
media ecology
metaphysics
mind
myth
nature
Naturphilosophie
neuroscience
Object-oriented ontology
Ontology
organism
Panpsychism
phenomenology
philosophy
physics
play
pluralism
politics
Process
Process philosophy
Psychedelics
Religion
science
soul
soul-making
space-time
Spirit
spirituality
technology
teleology
theology
time
world-soul
Posts I Like
Archives
Top Clicks
- academia.edu/27796967/2016_Shook_Pa…
- schumachercollege.org.uk/courses/sh…
- stephenerobbins.com/talks/Relativit…
- ciis.edu/faculty-and-staff-director…
- docs.google.com/document/d/1Gdm16zr…
- matthewsegall.files.wordpress.com/2…
- matthewsegall.files.wordpress.com/2…
- matthewsegall.files.wordpress.com/2…
- tomcarter12.wordpress.com
- garygoldbergmd.wordpress.com
Copyright

footnotes2plato.com by Matthew David Segall is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Blog Stats
- 641,908 hits
video coming?
Yep. I’ll post audio tonight. Video will take a few days.
great thanks matt !
A great paper advocating for a Whiteheadian reading of neurophenomenology: http://www.concrescence.org/index.php/ajpt/article/view/74/38
dmf, I’m just going to wait for the video to be uploaded instead of posting the audio. Should be ready early next week.
no worries, thanks again for sharing
OK, the video of this talk will be uploaded by someone from the ACS department on Thursday latest. Sorry for the delay…
Reblogged this on Skylight.
I’m thinking: may take a little time…certainly thought your final question was the only point at which it got interesting. Most of what he said could be got from Susan Blakemore and Les Lancaster’s work….he became more interesting as I say after you promted a new perspective. I was stunned by his total avoidance of the collective unconscious and Jung. The other initial observation is the extent to which a Cartesian view of object v subject dominated his view. i will try and be more thoughtful as time goes on and my self enacts a bit ! Tony.
Yes I think phenomenology is still somewhat Cartesian, though in Evan’s hands (following Merleau-Ponty) it has been given a more embodied twist than Husserl originally was able to give it.
I posted some crits on my blog http://www.hugofgaia. And my thanks for your letting me see this. Maybe you or your followers may want to see it. They would be welcome to visit as you say. I tried to include the laypeople who may not be philosophers or have even seen the presentation. And I think it was remiss I did not discuss “reenactment of self” but I had problems with “self” i guess. Would reenactment of “ego consciousness” be clearer. My view of “Self” is more Jungian than Evan’s I guess. This is hugely important I think.
Very cool, I look forward to reading what you’ve written up! Thanks, Tony.
Matt, what do you make of his rejection of pan-theism/psychism/Whitehead?
It seems to me that Evan was rejecting the Chalmers/Strawson version of panpsychism, wherein “mental” and “physical” are still treated as “states”/”substances.” I also reject this non-process-relational version of panpsychism (https://footnotes2plato.com/2013/07/01/panpsychism-and-philosophy/).
I see Whitehead’s process-relational approach to ontologizing experience as more akin to phenomenology than the sort of speculative philosophy Evan want’s to distance himself from. Whitehead’s whole project, after all, was to ground the abstractions of science in concrete experience. I think his approach is not only compatible with, but complementary to the enactive approach. It gives a cosmological ground to what otherwise remains stuck in a sort of purgatory of phenomenological bracketing. Lars Marstaller has written a fascinating paper that shows point by point how Whitehead’s and Husserl’s analyses of experience line up, making the case for a “Whiteheadian neurophenomenology”: http://concrescence.org/index.php/ajpt/article/download/74/38
Evan hasn’t yet taken the time to explore what Whitehead’s approach has to offer to ontologically rounding out the enactive approach, so far as I can tell. But in conversation about it he certainly seems open to this possibility. He falls back upon “neutral monism” for now, which to my mind still remains too caught up in how the world appears to human consciousness, how we represent reality (as either physical or mental), and is in that sense not speculative enough. Though again, I think Whitehead’s form of experientially grounded speculative philosophy (where the idea is to find the most basic features of human experience and then ruthlessly generalize them) breaks us out of the suffocating correlationist bubble.